Choosing the Right Interview Approach

How do you choose your interview approach? Are you even conscious of choosing an approach? Or do you tend to just fall into the same approach you used last time, and the time before, and the last 20 times? In today’s vlog post, Pete argues that your approach needs to be carefully designed to fit with the uniqueness of each interview, and shares two key variables to examine as you decide.

After you watch, share your opinion about it — We want to hear your thoughts!

Should Your Interview Be a Presentation… or a Conversation?

One of the most important strategic decisions you’ll make in an interview is this:

Do we present… or do we interact?

And the answer isn’t automatic.

It depends on two key factors — and both need to line up.

Factor #1: The Circumstances of the Interview

Start by looking at the situation around the interview itself.

Ask questions like:

  • How much do we already know?
  • Where are the gaps?
  • Would interaction help us better understand their needs?

Sometimes, the circumstances clearly point toward conversation.

Maybe there’s ambiguity in the project.

Maybe the client values collaboration.

Maybe asking questions would demonstrate how you think.

In those cases, shifting toward a more interactive format can be a huge advantage.

Factor #2: The People in the Room

But here’s where teams often miss the mark.

They decide based on the circumstances… and forget about the people.

Because not every selection committee is wired for interaction.

You might be dealing with:

  • Introverts who don’t like thinking on the spot
  • Reserved personalities who won’t engage openly
  • Political dynamics where people hold back their opinions

In those cases, asking a lot of questions can actually stall the interview instead of elevating it.

When It Works — and When It Doesn’t

Conversation works best when:

  • The situation calls for discovery
  • The people are willing to engage

It struggles when:

  • The room is guarded or quiet
  • People don’t want to reveal their thinking

And that’s the key:

Both factors need to align.

The Strategic Sweet Spot

The strongest teams don’t lock into one approach.

They read the room.

They assess both:

  • The circumstances
  • The people

And then they choose — or adjust — their approach accordingly.

Sometimes that means:

  • Leaning into conversation
  • Staying more structured
  • Or blending both

Final Thought

Turning an interview into a conversation can be powerful.

But only when the environment supports it.

If you want to get this right, don’t just ask:

“Should we interact more?”

Ask:

“Do the circumstances — and the people — make that the right move?”

That’s where great interview strategy lives.

No Comments yet!

Your Email address will not be published.

Receive weekly posts of insight and inspiration.